In your opinion who do consider the best qb ever?

[310stanger]

Aikman owes a lot to the brick wall offensive line that prevented him from actually ever getting blitzed

[toi tyme]

why do people hate on Eli so bad? I dont get it.

Idk. I don't hate him. I'm just not going to like him because of the association with his brother.

Unlike the Barber twins. I love them both

[310stanger]

Idk. I don't hate him. I'm just not going to like him because of the association with his brother.

Unlike the Barber twins. I love them both

ok well why dont you like him? Cause hes on the Giants?

fuck the barber twins and i say that with Tiki being a Giant great so to speak. He ran his mouth a lot and was a cry baby behind the scenes. Took him several seasons to stop fumbling the ball. then the year after he retires they go out and win the big game. Fuck Tiki Barber. I dont care if hes the giants rushing leader.

Rondae is a decent Corner though.

[toi tyme]

Also Johnny Unitas, he was really good.... Joe Montana and Joe Namath were really good.


Top three. Roger S, Montana and Namath.


Some would aruge P. Manning just got lucky. He's good. But not the best.


Aikman still, was very good. The triplets were my all tile fav with Smith and Irvin. They had great chemistry.



I'm POed right now with Romo and the cowboys so called secret weapon Roy williams. They just have no chemistry at all.

[SandmanWs7]

Tony Romo sux, why his name is even mentioned in this thread with REAL QB's is unacceptable.

[toi tyme]

ok well why dont you like him? Cause hes on the Giants?

fuck the barber twins and i say that with Tiki being a Giant great so to speak. He ran his mouth a lot and was a cry baby behind the scenes. Took him several seasons to stop fumbling the ball. then the year after he retires they go out and win the big game. Fuck Tiki Barber. I dont care if hes the giants rushing leader.

Rondae is a decent Corner though.

I hate the giants. I don't care if tiki sucks. Just like him.


No one was a better crybabie than Tarrel Owens! "don't make fun of my quaterback "


But also I think winning a superbowl doesn't make you the best QB l; like in Eli mannings concern.

[FasstChevys]

fuck Tiki being a Giant great so to speak. He ran his mouth a lot and was a cry baby behind the scenes. Took him several seasons to stop fumbling the ball. then the year after he retires they go out and win the big game. Fuck Tiki Barber. I dont care if hes the giants rushing leader.

Agree 1,000%

Tiki's a bitch for dogging his team/teammates like he did. I'm glad he wasn't part of the Giants' SuperBowl win

[toi tyme]

Tony Romo sux, why his name is even mentioned in this thread with REAL QB's is unacceptable.

I agree. I never said he should have been considered for the poll. He sucks.

[Murder after Midnight]

Tony Romo sux, why his name is even mentioned in this thread with REAL QB's is unacceptable.

+1 he did not even make the poll, I don't even know who brought him up....

[FasstChevys]

Vick, A. Manning, E. Manning, Moon, and Namath shouldn't be considerations for the "Greatest QB" of all time. Y.A. Tittle & Sammy Baugh are just a few that were better than all of the guys previously mentioned.

[Sarge]

Eddie LeBaron

[FasstChevys]

I agree. I never said he should have been considered for the poll. He sucks.

well, 'being mentioned in the thread' is different than being considered on the poll.......I think......

[310stanger]

I wont argue Namath being ON the list, i just dont think hes the greatest ever. But he definitely needs to be in the LIST of best ever as a whole. He was a great player

[310stanger]

I hate the giants. I don't care if tiki sucks. Just like him.


No one was a better crybabie than Tarrel Owens! "don't make fun of my quaterback "


But also I think winning a superbowl doesn't make you the best QB l; like in Eli mannings concern.

T.O is gonna implode very shortly with all the losing Buffalo is doing

[310stanger]

I hate the giants. I don't care if tiki sucks. Just like him.


No one was a better crybabie than Tarrel Owens! "don't make fun of my quaterback "


But also I think winning a superbowl doesn't make you the best QB l; like in Eli mannings concern.

I agree. But I also think inorder to be called the greatest of all time, you do have to have won a superbowl. Dan Marino has amazing stats but you cant call him the greatest ever when theres other qb's that have multiple super bowl wins and he never won

[FasstChevys]

I wont argue Namath being ON the list, i just dont think hes the greatest ever. But he definitely needs to be in the LIST of best ever as a whole. He was a great player

We definitely disagree on this one -

50% career completion percentage and more INT's than TD's and (unfortunately) was riddled with injuries a good part of his career...........he's a far cry from making this list........sorry.

[AfterYou]

i still think kurt warner

[Murder after Midnight]

Eddie LeBaron

LOL I know you were going to say some one from the 50-60's haha, seriously I heard he was damn good though............................

[Sarge]

Guy was fricking unreal. I used to go with my Dad....they played with a white football cuz the lights sucked....that lil shit would run like a jack rabbit and nobody could get-a-hold of his lil ass....he was great man....best QB I ever saw.

[Y2KPewterSS]

T.O is gonna implode very shortly with all the losing Buffalo is doing

Its coming soon, 3 catches today and another loss