In your opinion who do consider the best qb ever?

Printable View

Show 100 post(s) from this thread on one page

10-04-2009, 05:12 PM
Y2KPewterSS

Quote:

Originally Posted by toityme

Also Johnny Unitas, he was really good.... Joe Montana and Joe Namath were really good.

Top three. Roger S, Montana and Namath.

Some would aruge P. Manning just got lucky. He's good. But not the best.

Aikman still, was very good. The triplets were my all tile fav with Smith and Irvin. They had great chemistry.

I'm POed right now with Romo and the cowboys so called secret weapon Roy williams. They just have no chemistry at all.

Aikman/Emmitt/Irvin was the best trio Dallas will probably ever see. Novacek was a big part of that success too.

Romo is the biggest chump in the NFL these days. He isn't even a top 20 current QB, hence why Dallas is not a real contender. This is an 8-8 or 9-7 year for Dallas and no playoff birth. Giants win the east and the 3 powerhouses in the central will gobble up the wild cards.
10-04-2009, 05:12 PM
toi tyme

Quote:

Originally Posted by Y2KPewterSS

Its coming soon, 3 catches today and another loss :lmao:

i cant wait
10-04-2009, 05:15 PM
Y2KPewterSS

Quote:

Originally Posted by toityme

i cant wait

Me either, as long as he has been bottled up, it should be an entertaining, drama filled explosion :lol:
10-04-2009, 05:28 PM
FBracing1222

I would deff go Brady. 3 SB wins and 2 SB mvp's, plus he didn't have shit for WRs till moss and welker. And how ppl say manning has "bad" recievers I don't get. When he has Wayne and dallas Clark who is a monster at TE
10-04-2009, 05:49 PM
Murder after Midnight

Quote:

Originally Posted by FasstChevys

Vick, A. Manning, E. Manning, Moon, and Namath shouldn't be considerations for the "Greatest QB" of all time. Y.A. Tittle & Sammy Baugh are just a few that were better than all of the guys previously mentioned.

Sorry but I consider Moon and Namath great man......... Vick rushed for over a 1000 yards one season and was well on his way to becoming one of the greats before the dog fighting stuff, there was only twenty options
10-04-2009, 06:27 PM
ReBop

Drew Breez
10-04-2009, 07:03 PM
FasstChevys

Quote:

Originally Posted by Murder after Midnight

Sorry but I consider Moon and Namath great man......... Vick rushed for over a 1000 yards one season and was well on his way to becoming one of the greats before the dog fighting stuff, there was only twenty options

Y.A. Tittle & Sammy Baugh were better than those three.

Vick running for 1,000 yards is a great accomplishment - but doesn't put him in the running for "Greatest QB" ever.

Namath? Poor passing percentage and more INT's than TD's.......hardly great in my opinion. Trent Dilfer won a SuperBowl too -
10-04-2009, 07:05 PM
310stanger

Quote:

Originally Posted by FasstChevys

Y.A. Tittle & Sammy Baugh were better than those three.

Vick running for 1,000 yards is a great accomplishment - but doesn't put him in the running for "Greatest QB" ever.

Namath? Poor passing percentage and more INT's than TD's.......hardly great in my opinion. Trent Dilfer won a SuperBowl too -

The Trent Dilfer comment does make a good point. Trent Dilhole
10-04-2009, 07:09 PM
FasstChevys

Quote:

Originally Posted by 310stanger

The Trent Dilfer comment does make a good point. Trent Dilhole

I'm not even really trying to dog 'ol Broadway Joe - I'm just saying his performance doesn't put him on the same sheet of paper with Montana and the like.

I'll give credit to Joe for 'guaranteing victory', and then actually going out and doing it. :thumbup:
10-04-2009, 07:11 PM
310stanger

Quote:

Originally Posted by FasstChevys

I'm not even really trying to dog 'ol Broadway Joe - I'm just saying his performance doesn't put him on the same sheet of paper with Montana and the like.

I'll give credit to Joe for 'guaranteing victory', and then actually going out and doing it. :thumbup:

on a statistics perspective, your point is completely valid.
10-04-2009, 07:14 PM
00LS12LS6Z28

I voted for Joe Montana. I am not a 49er fan, but Montana to Rice plays were the best.
10-04-2009, 07:30 PM
02transamce

Elway.2 rings and more last minute comeback drives than any other qb.

that montana guy was good too.
10-04-2009, 08:40 PM
Murder after Midnight

Quote:

Originally Posted by FasstChevys

Y.A. Tittle & Sammy Baugh were better than those three.

Vick running for 1,000 yards is a great accomplishment - but doesn't put him in the running for "Greatest QB" ever.

Namath? Poor passing percentage and more INT's than TD's.......hardly great in my opinion. Trent Dilfer won a SuperBowl too -

ok man i can respect that............................
10-04-2009, 08:44 PM
310stanger

I will say this about Michael Vick, he MIGHT have the most RAW talent ever. Cannon of an arm, really strong, rocket fast runner, moves in the pocket like a gazelle. Shitty completion percentage though and doesnt really win. So nah, wont ever be in contention for best ever, but definitely one of the most talented. I think if they tested the arm strength of all the elite qb's in the league he'd be towards the very top and most people only think of him as a scrambler
10-04-2009, 08:44 PM
FasstChevys

Quote:

Originally Posted by Murder after Midnight

ok man i can respect that............................

it's all good - hell, it's just my opinion - it doesn't mean you have to agree....no big deal :cheers:
10-04-2009, 08:45 PM
FasstChevys

Quote:

Originally Posted by 310stanger

I will say this about Michael Vick, he MIGHT have the most RAW talent ever. Cannon of an arm, really strong, rocket fast runner, moves in the pocket like a gazelle. Shitty completion percentage though and doesnt really win. So nah, wont ever be in contention for best ever, but definitely one of the most talented. I think if they tested the arm strength of all the elite qb's in the league he'd be towards the very top and most people only think of him as a scrambler

without a doubt - he's an incredible athlete, no question
10-04-2009, 08:48 PM
El Toro Loco

Joe Montana, number one and very close second tie i would have to say Troy Aikman and Peyton Manning, troy still is considered one of the most accurate if not the most accurate quarterback to play only thing was he became concussion prone late in his career and peyton well what is there not to say and probably once his career is over he will be considered the best cant consider him the best when he still can achieve more..
10-04-2009, 08:51 PM
Murder after Midnight

Quote:

Originally Posted by 310stanger

I will say this about Michael Vick, he MIGHT have the most RAW talent ever. Cannon of an arm, really strong, rocket fast runner, moves in the pocket like a gazelle. Shitty completion percentage though and doesnt really win. So nah, wont ever be in contention for best ever, but definitely one of the most talented. I think if they tested the arm strength of all the elite qb's in the league he'd be towards the very top and most people only think of him as a scrambler

Agreed +1

With the right accuracy, completion percentage, focus and team he could of been the greatest ever...............
10-04-2009, 08:52 PM
310stanger

Let me add that although i picked Montana, I've always been a huge Elway fan, even when the broncos were considered somewhat of a Giants rival persay. John Elway had a cannon of an arm. Probably the strongest in NFL history.
10-04-2009, 08:53 PM
310stanger

Quote:

Originally Posted by Murder after Midnight

Agreed +1

With the right accuracy, completion percentage, focus and team he could of been the greatest ever...............

Thats a lot of things, but yes with all those qualities being as good or better then the other Qb's we've mentioned and some super bowl rings, yes. He could have

Show 100 post(s) from this thread on one page